From traditional pumpkin and apple pies to irresistible local specialties, here are some Colorado bakeries worth checking out for your Thanksgiving table.
Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and while turkey might be the centerpiece of the meal, I think we can all agree that dessert deserves a little attention, too!
There's something special about finishing a Thanksgiving dinner with a delicious slice of pie. Whether you're a pumpkin pie traditionalist, love a classic apple pie, or prefer something rich and chocolatey, Colorado has some wonderful local bakeries ready to make the holiday a little sweeter.
And the best part? You don't have to spend hours in the kitchen making everything from scratch.
If you're hosting Thanksgiving this year, visiting family, or simply looking for something delicious to bring to the table, here are some Colorado pie shops worth knowing about.
1. Legacy Pie Co. — Denver
If you're looking for a great pie without leaving Denver, Legacy Pie Co. is an excellent place to start.
With locations on Tennyson Street and near Washington Park, this local bakery offers sweet and savory pies in different sizes, making it a convenient option whether you're hosting a large gathering or planning a smaller Thanksgiving celebration.
One thing I particularly like about the concept is the variety. Sometimes everyone at the table wants something different, and having a selection of smaller pies can make dessert a little more fun.
Thanksgiving tip: Legacy Pie Co. is offering Thanksgiving preorders for 2026, along with a holiday pickup pop-up at Aspen Grove from November 23–25.
2. Ginger and Baker — Fort Collins
If you're celebrating Thanksgiving in Northern Colorado, Ginger and Baker deserves a spot on your list.
Located in a historic grain mill in Fort Collins, this destination combines a scratch bakery with restaurants, a café, and a market.
Their pie selection includes traditional favorites and more indulgent creations, such as double-crust apple pie, coconut cream pie, and chocolate pie.
It's the kind of place that makes picking up dessert feel like a special outing rather than another errand.
Thanksgiving tip: Check their holiday ordering menu for this year's selection, preorder availability, and pickup arrangements.
3. Granny Scott's Pie Shop — Lakewood
For anyone in Lakewood or the western Denver suburbs, Granny Scott's Pie Shop is another local option worth exploring.
The shop has been serving the community since 1994 and offers a wide selection of pies alongside other baked goods and casual lunch options.
If you love traditional neighborhood bakeries, this is the kind of place that deserves a look.
Their October and November seasonal spotlight includes pumpkin cheesecake, which could be a fun alternative to traditional pumpkin pie.
Thanksgiving tip: Contact the bakery directly to confirm holiday availability and ordering deadlines.
4. Gold Star Bakery — Colorado Springs
Heading south for Thanksgiving?
Gold Star Bakery in Colorado Springs is offering holiday pie preorders for 2026.
If you're planning to bring dessert to a family gathering, ordering ahead can save you the last-minute scramble.
Thanksgiving tip: The published preorder deadline is Monday, November 16, with pickup scheduled for November 24 and 25 at The Blue Star Restaurant between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m.
These details are particularly helpful for anyone traveling or coordinating a holiday meal.
5. You Need Pie! — Estes Park
With a name like You Need Pie!, how could you not be curious?
This Estes Park bakery offers whole pies in different sizes, making it a fun stop for anyone celebrating Thanksgiving near Rocky Mountain National Park.
Whether you're spending the holiday in Estes Park or visiting family nearby, it's a local business worth keeping in mind.
Thanksgiving tip: The bakery is accepting Thanksgiving orders through November 18, with pickup on November 25.
6. Palisade Pie Shop — Palisade
If your Thanksgiving plans take you to Colorado's Western Slope, Palisade Pie Shop offers something especially fitting for the season.
This family-owned bakery specializes in fruit pies, with some fruit sourced from the family's own orchard.
Palisade is already known for its agricultural heritage, and a locally made fruit pie feels like a lovely way to bring a little Western Colorado flavor to the holiday table.
Thanksgiving tip: Check directly with the shop for seasonal flavors, holiday hours, and advance ordering requirements.
7. 3.14 Pi Bar — Colorado Springs
For something a little different, 3.14 Pi Bar in Colorado Springs offers both sweet pies and savory pot pies.
That makes it an interesting option if you're looking beyond the traditional Thanksgiving dessert lineup.
Their 2026 Thanksgiving menu is available for advance ordering, with pickup scheduled for November 23–25.
It's another reminder that local bakeries can offer some creative alternatives to the usual holiday staples.
A Few Tips Before Ordering Your Thanksgiving Pies
Thanksgiving is one of the busiest times of the year for bakeries, so planning ahead is always a good idea.
Check preorder deadlines, confirm pickup locations, and make sure your preferred flavor is available before placing an order.
It's also worth asking about storage instructions, especially if you're picking up your pies a day or two before Thanksgiving.
And remember, a great Thanksgiving dessert doesn't have to be complicated. Sometimes a beautiful pie from a local bakery is exactly what the table needs.
A Little Something Sweet for the Holiday Season
One of the things I love about Colorado is the incredible variety of local businesses that make our communities special.
From Denver and Lakewood to Fort Collins, Colorado Springs, Estes Park, and Palisade, there are so many wonderful places to explore and support.
Whether you're celebrating Thanksgiving in your longtime family home or hosting your first holiday in a new place, I hope your table is filled with delicious food, good company, and plenty of reasons to be grateful.
And if finding a new home in Colorado is part of your plans for the coming year, I'd love to help you find a place where you can create many more holiday memories.
